Jews and Islam

Islamic world has sheltered Jewish people throughout history: rabbi

Tehran Times Political Desk

Jews and Islam

TEHRAN — Israel must end its military occupation of Palestine because that is
the only way that there can be peaceful negotiations that will resolve the
longstanding dispute, Rabbi Lynn Gottlieb said here last week.
Rabbi Gottlieb, one of the first ten women rabbis in the history of Judaism,
on May 10 visited the offices of the Tehran Times and the Mehr News
Agency, heading a delegation of 21 peace activists from the United States.

The interfaith delegation included people of Jewish, Muslim, Buddhist,
Christian, and Indigenous religious confessions from 11 different U.S. states.

“It is important to remember that the Islamic world has sheltered the Jewish
people throughout our long history,” Rabbi Gottlieb said in an interview with

Following are some excerpts of the interview:

Q: You have visited many Iranian Jews during your trip. Do they like living in
Iran? What is your view of them?

A: I am the first woman rabbi to visit Iran. I had the opportunity to visit and
attend religious services at Tehran’s synagogue, with the rest of the
members of this delegation as well, to visit the Jewish hospital, and to hear
from (outgoing Jewish MP) Morris Motamed and Siamak Mursadeq, who is
the future parliamentarian. Several of us also visited the Jewish community
in Shiraz and we also met a Jewish shop owner and his son in Isfahan, and
we also shared a meal with Mr. Mursadeq in his home and had a lengthy
conversation. And as well, we have visited the Armenian (Orthodox
Christian) religious community. For me personally, that was very moving and
very exciting.

It’s important for us to know about this ancient Jewish community (in Iran),
which is the oldest community outside of Israel that exists in the world, and
has preserved the traditional ways of Jewish people, and everyone that we
have spoken to, whether they have visited Israel or not, has affirmed that
they have in Iran only some minor challenges, such as the inheritance law.
But we know that there is openness in the parliament and with the Supreme
Leader, and among the population, to resolve those challenges… They are
of Middle Eastern origin and have a unique perspective to offer us in
maintaining a good relationship with their Christian and Muslim brothers and
sisters and have been living in peace with their neighbors for 30 centuries.

[Mention should been made of the Iraqi Babylonian Jews that have lived
there continuously since the time of their exile in Babylon]

For much of the world Jewish community, whose history often reflects the
difficult times they have had in Europe, it is important to remember that the
Islamic world has sheltered the Jewish people throughout our long history.

We are so saddened, not just as Jews but as Americans, and in this I know I
reflect the feeling of the whole delegation, at how tragic and unnecessary
the war and the American invasion of Iraq has been, and we are deeply
distressed at the destruction of the Iraqi culture and people and we are
praying for a speedy withdrawal of American forces from Iraq.

(Here) we have eaten well, we have been graciously hosted, we have loved
the people of Iran, and we have had wonderful conversations… This is a
community that expresses many different views within the context of a
tremendous spirit of hospitality, which we have so appreciated. And that is
the tradition we share. Abraham was known for his great hospitality, and in
Jewish tradition this is the reason that he is known as a prophet among us
not only for his revelation of tawhid (monotheism), but also because his
revelation of tawhid and unity came with his extensive hospitality to
strangers. We also learned that it was Cyrus who returned the Jews first to
the land of Israel after they were first exiled and helped us rebuild our
temple there. He also wrote the first declaration of human rights in human
history. We honor the people of Iran for this advanced understanding that
human rights must be the heart of any religious expression.

Q: The 60th anniversary of the establishment of Israel is approaching. Is it
justifiable that, based on its past problems, one nation should treat another
nation in the same way as it was treated before and create the same
problems for that nation?

A: When I was 17 years old, I had the opportunity to go to high school in
Israel, in Haifa. And I also attended university there. And since that time I
have returned to Israel almost every year. Most recently, in the past 12
years, I have led seven delegations from this organization, Fellowship of
Reconciliation, to Israel and to Palestine. The first year that I was in Israel, I
remember being very excited, of course, and driving up the hill to
Jerusalem, and seeing lights on the side of the road and I asked Zev Vilnay,
who was the grandfather of tourism in Israel, “Who lives there?” And he told
me those are Arab villagers.

And in my innocence and youth, I didn’t know the history of the Middle East.
At that time I was anxious to learn, because from my own history, both the
Holocaust and knowing the loss of human lives there, and the civil rights
movement in Israel, and the struggle of African Americans to attain human
rights, and the genocide of Native American people in the United States,
which is an ongoing issue… Anyway, I went to see Mansour, the Palestinian
journalist… I went to his house, by myself, with my Israeli host, who was my
age. We knocked on his door, we were invited in, he served tea, and I said,
“I am here to interview Mansour.” I had no appointment. He was very
shocked, but he granted me the interview. He said, “Why do you want to
interview me?” And I said, “Mr. Mansour, can you tell me what it’s like to be
an Israeli Arab?” That was the term I used. And he looked at me and he said
to me, “Young woman, if you want to know my story, I will tell you, but if I tell
you my story, then you will have responsibility for that knowledge.” I said, “I
want to know your story.” And he told me the story of the Nakba, of the
expulsion of 750,000 Palestinians from their homes, the destruction of over
400 villages at that time in 1948. I was 17.

Since that time, 41 years ago, I have been working constantly on raising up,
in my own community and in the Christian community in the United States,
the desire of Palestinians for national sovereignty in their own land. And in
this period of time, earlier it was calling for negotiations between the PLO
and Israel, just as this delegation is calling… and in this current time, calling
for an end to Israel’s military occupation of Palestine as the only way that will
allow peaceful negotiations and a settlement between our peoples.

Q: How do you evaluate the role of interfaith dialogue in achieving world

A: This delegation represents the possibility of world peace in the very
nature of our coming together. We as a delegation travel together in an
interfaith context to promote the role of interfaith dialogue as an invaluable
resource in promoting peace. If we can travel together, sit together, eat
together, talk together, get to know each other, maintain our unity, and learn
from each other, this can be an example of the peace that is possible, and
we found this very much reflected in Iran. There is freedom of religion here;
we have discovered it in our travels. And perhaps our work together can be
an example and model of interfaith dialogue on both the level of clergy or
religious leaders and among the community itself. We advocate both
dialogue among people as well as leaders.

Q: Is there any way to stop disrespect toward religions?

A: The media in the United States, for instance, could work a lot harder to
promote religious understanding, especially of Shiism… Personally, I don’t
think it’s as much a problem of religions as it is politics. Some people use
religion to separate. Those of us who care about world peace must lift up
those things in our tradition that help us find common ground. We are all cut
from the same jewel.

After the events of 9/11, when planes were flown into the World Trade
Center Towers and the Pentagon, and there was a third plane that did not
reach its destination, the religious community in the United States, all across
the United States, reached out to the Muslim community.

In my own situation, my Sunni partner in dialogue and I cofounded the
Muslim-Jewish peace walk. Our idea was very simple. Pilgrimage is common
to the Christian, Jewish, and Muslim faiths. Our idea was that we should all
dress in white, which is the pilgrimage garment, and carry no signs except
for peace, and walk in a peaceful pilgrimage from a synagogue, to a church,
to a mosque and to go inside as a religious community. Everyone was

We had the first peace walk in Mexico five years ago. We had participation
from the Jewish, Muslim, Protestant, Catholic, Hindu, Native American, and
Buddhist communities. Everyone came inside the synagogue and offered
prayers for peace in their own religious tradition, and then we went to the
masjid (mosque) and people went inside. So you can imagine what it’s like to
be inside a masjid and have a Jewish rabbi and a Christian priest and a
Buddhist monk and a Native American spiritual elder and so forth offering
prayers in the mosque, in the name of peace. That also occurred in a
synagogue and a church, and in this way we truly enacted the idea that all of
us are one religion. While we respect the differences in each religion, of
course, is it not good to offer prayers for peace for each other in our holy

This walk is in its fifth year, and it has spread to 16 different cities
throughout the United States and Canada.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s